Used vs New Tires: The Real Cost Per Mile
Used tires cost less up front — but are they actually cheaper per mile? The fair way to compare a used tire and a new tire is cost per 32nd of usable tread, and then think about age and warranty. Here's how to run the numbers on any two tires.
The formula
Cost per usable 32nd = installed price ÷ (current tread depth − 2)
You subtract 2 because tires are worn out at 2/32". Include mounting, balancing and disposal so you're comparing the real cost.
A worked example
These numbers are only an example to show the math — plug in the real prices and tread depths of the tires you're looking at.
New tire: $160 installed, 10/32" → 8 usable 32nds → $20 per 32nd
Used tire: $75 installed, 7/32" → 5 usable 32nds → $15 per 32nd
Worn used tire: $70 installed, 4/32" → 2 usable 32nds → $35 per 32nd
The takeaway: a good used tire with healthy tread is often cheaper per mile than new. A low-tread used tire is cheap up front but expensive per mile — it only makes sense as a short-term fix.
Things the formula doesn't cover
Age: an old tire may age out before the tread wears out. Check the DOT date — see how old is too old?
Warranty: new tires often carry a manufacturer mileage warranty. Used tires at Lexington Discount Tires come with a 30-day warranty.
Your timeline: if you're selling the car or leaving town in a year, paying for 50,000 miles of new tread you won't use isn't savings.
Matching: replacing one tire on an AWD vehicle often favors a used tire that matches the others — see one used tire on an AWD car.
When new makes more sense
You drive a lot of highway miles and keep cars for years
You want a specific performance, winter or all-terrain model
There's no used tire in your size with good tread right now
We sell both. Compare used tires in Lexington KY with new tires, or call (859) 900-1234 and we'll price both for your size.

Comments